Introduction
With the rapid growth of artificial intelligence (AI), the issue of how AI is used in businesses is becoming more prominent.
For Australian businesses, there has been a growing use of AI in boardrooms to summarise information, analyse documents and help directors navigate large volumes of material.
However, a recent Federal Court decision has provided an important warning in relation to AI use by directors. The decision highlighted that while AI may assist directors, it cannot take responsibility for their decisions or replace a directors’ personal responsibility to exercise informed human judgement.
In Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Bekier (Liability Judgment) [2026] FCA 196 (AISC v Bekier), Justice Michael Lee considered the responsibilities of directors in the context of information overload and the increasing use of AI. While this specific case concerned governance failures at The Star Entertainment Group, a large public company, the Court’s comments have broader implications for all directors of Australian businesses, including SMEs.
Please note that the observations made by Justice Lee in this case relating to AI were made in the broad context of His Honour’s consideration of director duties and information overload. This case has not established a standalone legal duty relating to the use of AI by directors.
Key article takeaways
- The Federal Court’s 2026 decision in ASIC v Bekier reinforces the importance of directors actively engaging with information and exercising informed judgement.
- AI tools can assist directors with reviewing board papers, analysing information and preparing for decisions, but they should not replace independent human judgement.
- The duty of care and diligence under section 180(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) remains a personal responsibility.
- Directors should consider appropriate AI governance policies, human verification procedures and safeguards for confidential business information.
- While the case concerned a large public company, its observations provide useful guidance for SME directors considering how AI should be used within their businesses.
Too much information
One of the key concerns raised by Justice Lee in this case was the sheer volume of information that is being provided to boards.
Excessive board materials can make it difficult for directors to identify and consider information that is important to their role.
The issue of too much information becomes more prominent where important information is buried within hundreds of pages of reports and attachments.
However, having too much information to read through does not negate a director’s responsibility to understand and critically consider information relevant to their role.
The Court reinforced that directors have a personal obligation to take a “diligent and intelligent interest” in information available to them, no matter how much information there is.
AI’s role
In today’s society, the issue of information overload for directors is often being resolved by deploying AI tools that are capable of:
- Summarising lengthy board papers;
- Identifying key issues;
- Comparing documents;
- Extracting information from large datasets;
- Helping prepare for questions; and
- Assisting with the analysis of board materials.
Some of these uses are valid, and Justice Lee acknowledged that there is a potential for AI to assist directors in discharging their duties and navigating large volumes of information.
However, the caveat to this is that assistance cannot turn into reliance. AI cannot assume the directors’ responsibility for understanding, questioning and exercising their own judgement.
AI cannot replace a director’s judgement
The Court in this case does not suggest that directors cannot use AI in their role. Rather, the message sent by the Court was that AI should not become a substitute for a director’s own analysis and judgement.
For example, a director that receives an AI-generated summary of a board pack cannot simply rely on that summary without first considering whether the underlying information provided to the AI tool has been accurately and adequately understood.
The importance of engaging with the source material stems from the fact that AI tools can and are known to miss information, misinterpret information or place emphasis on the wrong information.
The other issue raised is that an AI summary can influence what a director considers important, potentially without a director realising that their view has been shaped by AI’s interpretation of the source material.
The Court’s message from this case is clear: the statutory duty prescribed under section 180(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) remains a personal duty that requires informed human judgement and technology does not transfer that duty to someone or something else.
Related Article: Personal Liability for Company Directors
Shadow governance
Another key component of Justice Lee’s comments was the need for boards to deliberately consider how AI is being used.
Justice Lee specifically indicated that boards should not tolerate informal or “shadow” use of AI and its usage should be discussed and deliberately governed through clear policies and procedures.
This also becomes more important where directors or management use AI tools to process confidential company information.
Related Article: Why Your Service Contract Needs A Clear AI Clause
What does this mean for SME directors?
While this case relates to a publicly listed company, the principles communicated apply to all businesses.
AI usage is increasingly being used across all businesses of all sizes.
As a result, directors of all businesses, including SMEs, should consider whether their existing governance arrangements adequately address AI usage and whether appropriate safeguards are in place.
Directors should also ensure that their use of AI does not result in them becoming less engaged with important business information or decisions so that they are still complying with their personal duties as a director.
What should businesses do?
This case does not suggest that AI should be banned from your business and its boardroom.
Rather, businesses should focus on using AI responsibly, including by:
- Establishing an AI policy;
- Protecting confidential information and considering what information can be safely entered into AI tools;
- Ensuring all AI generated information is reviewed and verified by a human before it is relied on;
- Engaging with source material, not just AI summaries;
- Reviewing governance arrangements; and
- Documenting important decisions, including when and how AI is used.
Conclusion
The AI related comments made by Justice Lee in ASIC v Bekier are not intended to suggest that directors should ban or avoid AI usage. Rather, it reinforces the fundamental principle that technology can assist a director but it does not replace the director’s own judgement.
AI may make it easier to process information and prepare for decisions. However, the responsibility of understanding the relevant information, asking questions, challenging assumptions and exercising judgement remains with the director.
As the use of AI continues to expand, directors should consider how AI can be used responsibly without compromising their duties as a director.
Is Your Business Managing AI-Related Legal Risks?
Artificial intelligence can create valuable opportunities for businesses, but it also introduces legal, confidentiality and governance considerations that should not be overlooked.
LawBase helps Australian business owners and directors understand their legal obligations, manage commercial risks and put practical protections in place as technology evolves.
Whether your business is reviewing how AI is used or seeking advice about directors’ duties, our team can help you navigate the legal considerations with confidence.
Additional resources
Australian Government
Guiding safe and responsible use of artificial intelligence in Australia.
View ResourceAustralian Government
Guidance on privacy and the use of commercially available AI products.
View ResourceFrequently asked questions
There is no universal requirement arising from ASIC v Bekier for every Australian company to adopt a formal AI governance policy.
However, having an AI policy is a sensible risk management measure, particularly where directors, employees or management use AI to process confidential information or support business decisions.
An AI policy can establish appropriate uses, confidentiality safeguards, approval processes, human review requirements and responsibilities for AI-generated information.
For SMEs, the policy should be proportionate to the nature of the business and the risks associated with its use of AI.
Potentially. Company directors can face personal consequences where their conduct breaches applicable directors’ duties.
The use of AI does not automatically create liability, but neither does it protect directors from responsibility for their decisions.
If a director relies on inaccurate or incomplete AI-generated information without exercising the care and diligence required in the circumstances, their conduct may raise legal concerns.
Whether a breach has occurred will depend on the particular facts, the director’s responsibilities and the applicable law.
Yes. Australian company directors can use artificial intelligence to assist with reviewing information, analysing documents and preparing for business decisions.
However, using AI does not remove a director’s legal responsibilities. Directors must continue to exercise appropriate care, diligence and independent judgement when making decisions on behalf of the company.
AI should be used as a supporting tool, rather than a replacement for understanding important business information and assessing relevant risks.
AI-generated summaries can assist directors in reviewing board papers and identifying important information, but directors should be cautious about relying on them without appropriate verification.
AI tools can omit important details, misinterpret information or present inaccurate conclusions. This can create risks where directors use summaries to make significant business decisions.
Directors should ensure they have sufficient access to, and understanding of, the underlying information and make appropriate enquiries before relying on AI-assisted analysis.
Using AI does not change the duty of care and diligence imposed on directors under section 180(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
Directors remain responsible for exercising their powers and discharging their duties with the care and diligence required in their circumstances.
An AI-generated recommendation does not transfer that responsibility to the AI provider or the technology itself.
Directors should understand the limitations of AI and exercise appropriate human oversight when using it to support important decisions.
Shadow AI use occurs when directors, management or employees use artificial intelligence tools informally without appropriate organisational oversight, approval or governance.
For example, a director might upload confidential board papers into a publicly available AI tool without considering the company’s confidentiality obligations or the tool’s data-handling practices.
In ASIC v Bekier, Justice Lee highlighted the importance of transparently governing AI use instead of tolerating informal or undisclosed practices.
Businesses should consider implementing clear policies that establish which AI tools can be used and what information may be shared with them.
In ASIC v Bekier (Liability Judgment) [2026] FCA 196, Justice Michael Lee considered the challenges of information overload and the increasing use of AI to assist company directors.
The Court acknowledged that AI could help directors process large volumes of information but cautioned against relying on AI-generated summaries as a substitute for properly considering board materials.
Justice Lee also emphasised the importance of transparency and appropriate governance when AI is used within boardroom processes.
The decision did not establish a new standalone legal duty relating to AI. Rather, the observations reinforce the existing responsibility of directors to exercise care, diligence and informed judgement.
Yes. LawBase provides commercially focused legal advice to Australian business owners, founders and company directors.
Depending on the circumstances, this may include advising on directors’ obligations, reviewing business contracts, addressing confidentiality and privacy risks, and helping businesses establish appropriate legal protections around AI use.
If your business is introducing AI into its operations or decision-making processes, obtaining legal advice can help identify potential risks and determine which safeguards are appropriate.
Schedule a CallThe information in this article is for general purposes only and you should obtain professional advice relevant to your specific circumstances.
Related Resources
Contracts
Transparency with AI: Why Your Service Contract Needs A Clear AI Clause
Using AI in your business? Learn why AI disclosure clauses in service contracts are best practice and what to include to manage legal risk and client expectations.
Read moreContracts Dispute Resolution & Litigation LawBase Newsletter Regulatory and Compliance Small Business Startups
AI Can’t Replace Your Lawyer: How LawBase Uses AI
In this article, we explore how LawBase uses AI to streamline legal processes while highlighting why technology can never replace the wisdom, judgement, and personal guidance clients receive from experienced legal professionals.
Read more

